Forest has duty to educate about risk of recreating

Print Article

Flathead Forest Supervisor Chip Weber ignores the advice of his own staff and grizzly bear experts, suggesting we consider all recreational activities to have an equal basis of risk when deciding whether to promote them. His staff and other bear experts note in their Board of Review recommendations against trail running and mountain biking that negative encounters between bears and bikers are “disproportionately high” compared to those with hikers.

Mr. Weber instead uses Wikipedia data on bear-caused human deaths that is not adjusted to be proportional to the frequency of the recreation type. He’s trying to make it look like walking and hiking are the more dangerous activities when they are instead simply among the most popular. He goes on to urge people to take risks according to their own values and to “own the consequences of your choices.”

Consequences, however, are not equal. When someone drowns in a river, the government doesn’t drain the river. When someone tangles with a bear, too often the government kills the bear that was simply defending itself or its cubs.

The current debate is not about ending trail running or mountain biking in bear habitat. It is about the Forest Service’s duty to educate the public about how speed increases the risk of injury or death to people and bears. It is about not issuing commercial permits for foot and bike races that instead send exactly the wrong message to forest visitors.

Supervisor Weber is in the process of building another 79 miles of mountain bike trails in bear habitat and encouraging reckless behavior on those trails. He is also rewarding his private trail-building partners with permits to commercially promote irresponsible behavior on those trails. Then he’ll wrongly blame “too many bears” for the conflicts that ensue. That is not leadership.

Keith J. Hammer is the Chair of the Swan View Coalition.

Print Article

Read More

Robert R. Collins

July 17, 2019 at 12:30 pm | Whitefish Pilot Robert R. Collins, 87, of Whitefish, passed away peacefully July 8, 2019 at the Montana Veterans Home. Robert is survived by his wife Barbara, daughter Chris Zignego and son Robert Collins Jr. Arra...

Comments

Read More

Couple grateful for those who assisted with flat tire

July 17, 2019 at 12:30 pm | Whitefish Pilot We are 80 year-old Canadians who have been coming to Whitefish for over 40 years. Recently we were driving down from Kimberley and stopped for dinner at Point of Rocks Restaurant about 25 miles west ...

Comments

Read More

Whitefish, pleasant surprise

July 17, 2019 at 12:30 pm | Whitefish Pilot What a surprise Whitefish is! We are traveling around the USA from Australia. When looking for places to stay we were dissuaded to stay in Whitefish, instead persuaded to Kalispell, as the forum we ...

Comments

Read More

Cautious of water conservation

July 17, 2019 at 12:30 pm | Whitefish Pilot To the citizens of Whitefish; putting aside the remaining and unanswered questions about how the city let itself get into a position of having to limit water use citywide when no other town in the va...

Comments

Read More

Contact Us

(406) 862-3505
312 E. Second Street
Whitefish, MT 59937

©2019 Whitefish Pilot Terms of Use Privacy Policy
X
X